Posted by Pete C. on November 4, 2008, 7:32 pm
daestrom wrote:
>
> Pete C. wrote:
> > clare@snyder.on.ca wrote:
> >>
> >> On Tue, 4 Nov 2008 07:27:28 +0800, "Norman Webb"
> >>
> >>>
> >>> Norman Webb wrote in message
> >>>>
> >>>> I have read/heard somewhere in the past that 2 transformer 3-phase
> >>>> isnâ?Tt same as industrial service 3-phase â?" is there a
> >>>> difference between residential 3-phase and industrial 3-phase?
> >>>>
> >>>> ##### three phase is three phase. There is difference whether it
> >>>> is used as a star or delta configuration. (I did electrical
> >>>> engineering nearly 30 years ago ,so I am a bit rusty too)
> >>>>
> >>>> ####How many wires are on the power poles out the front? 4 wires
> >>>> means three phase. I haven't heard of two trnasformer, three
> >>>> phase. Is it Single primary with three secondary windings?
> >>>
> >>> Just looked at my statement above. Three phase has each phase out
> >>> of phase by 120 deg so I can't figure out how it would work.
> >>>
> >> You have 208, not 220 volts.
> >
> > No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts
> > commonly comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has
> > open delta service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild
> > leg" to watch out for as well.
> >
> > The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non
> > center tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to
> > watch out for and he didn't have three phase service.
> >
> > His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one
> > of the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the
> > 110/220 house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch"
> > loads has the same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the
> > additional third hot leg provided from the other transformer. This
> > ranch panel if it does not have the neutral fed into it will be a
> > straight 220 volt three phase delta service. If the neutral leg is
> > present there, he can put 110 volt loads on as well, but has to be
> > careful because the third leg is the "wild leg" and is 208V relative
> > to that neutral, not 110V like the other two hot legs.
> >
>
> Well, the 'wild leg' as you call it isn't exactly 208V. If the
> center-tapped side is truly 110/220 and the smaller transformer is also 220,
> then from the third phase to neutral is only 190V.
>
> But still, it's different enough that if you mistakenly use it instead of
> one of the 'hot' legs from the larger, center-tapped transformer, it will
> blow whatever 110V load you hook up to it.
>
> daestrom
Yes and all the voltages are very "nominal".
Posted by tabers7823 on November 4, 2008, 6:23 pm
> cl...@snyder.on.ca wrote:
> > wrote:
> > >Norman Webb wrote in message
> > >>I have read/heard somewhere in the past that 2 transformer 3-phase
> > >>isn’t same as industrial service 3-phase – is there a difference
> > >>between residential 3-phase and industrial 3-phase?
> > >>##### three phase is three phase. There is difference whether it is used as
> > >>a star or delta configuration. (I did electrical engineering nearly 30
> > >years
> > >>ago ,so I am a bit rusty too)
> > >>####How many wires are on the power poles out the front? 4 wires means
> > >three
> > >>phase. I haven't heard of two trnasformer, three phase. Is it Single
> > >primary
> > >>with three secondary windings?
> > >Just looked at my statement above. Three phase has each phase out of phase
> > >by 120 deg so I can't figure out how it would work.
> > You have 208, not 220 volts.
> No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts commonly
> comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has open delta
> service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild leg" to watch
> out for as well.
> The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non center
> tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to watch out
> for and he didn't have three phase service.
> His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one of
> the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the 110/220
> house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch" loads has the
> same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the additional third hot
> leg provided from the other transformer. This ranch panel if it does not
> have the neutral fed into it will be a straight 220 volt three phase
> delta service. If the neutral leg is present there, he can put 110 volt
> loads on as well, but has to be careful because the third leg is the
> "wild leg" and is 208V relative to that neutral, not 110V like the other
> two hot legs.
> Diagrams help a lot with this, but I don't think I'm up to trying to
> draw transformers in ASCII art. There should be some sites with diagrams
> if you search for "open delta" and "wild leg". Certainly the OP should
> not go messing around much with his new found three phase service before
> finding such diagrams and understanding them.- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -
Thanks Pete – I think you are spot on. Apologies I erred in the
original post – I have 4 wires coming from pole – I didn’t realize
until closer examination that the support/anchor cable for the 3 hot
wires was also the ‘neutral’ 4th wire (and I so figured the ground
connections I asked about in original post are fine)
Wish I could attach diagram at end of this website - see:
http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=157326
It must be my exact 3-phase setup. From that diagram - measuring
between (house inputs) ‘a’, ‘b’, and ‘c’ I measure 240, 238, an=
d 235
volts ( I can not easily measure ‘c’ (wild leg) to neutral to see if
209 volts exist there). BTW – the ‘ranch panel’ DOES have 110
circuits.
Something bothering me is that I get 240V between ‘a’ and ‘b’, but
only 108 and 105 volts from those points to neutral (measured at
breaker box bus bar and bar input cable roof anchor) – I was expecting
120 volts (not 105 volts).
Thank you Pete, and Norman, for the input – I learned much…
Posted by Norman Webb on November 4, 2008, 6:42 pm
Pete C. wrote in message
>clare@snyder.on.ca wrote:
>>
>> wrote:
>>
>> >
>No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts commonly
>comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has open delta
>service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild leg" to watch
>out for as well.
>The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non center
>tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to watch out
>for and he didn't have three phase service.
>His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one of
>the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the 110/220
>house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch" loads has the
>same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the additional third hot
>leg provided from the other transformer. This ranch panel if it does not
>have the neutral fed into it will be a straight 220 volt three phase
>delta service. If the neutral leg is present there, he can put 110 volt
>loads on as well, but has to be careful because the third leg is the
>"wild leg" and is 208V relative to that neutral, not 110V like the other
>two hot legs.
>Diagrams help a lot with this, but I don't think I'm up to trying to
>draw transformers in ASCII art. There should be some sites with diagrams
>if you search for "open delta" and "wild leg". Certainly the OP should
>not go messing around much with his new found three phase service before
>finding such diagrams and understanding them.
I'll have to have a think about this but what about the phase of each leg?
A centre tapped transformer will be in phase or 180 degrees out of phase.
A three phase induction motor works with the 3 phases 120 degrees out of
phase.
In the mean time I'll google "open Delta"
Regards
Norm
Posted by Pete C. on November 4, 2008, 7:36 pm
Norman Webb wrote:
>
> Pete C. wrote in message
> >
> >clare@snyder.on.ca wrote:
> >>
> >> wrote:
> >>
> >> >
> >
> >No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts commonly
> >comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has open delta
> >service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild leg" to watch
> >out for as well.
> >
> >The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non center
> >tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to watch out
> >for and he didn't have three phase service.
> >
> >His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one of
> >the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the 110/220
> >house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch" loads has the
> >same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the additional third hot
> >leg provided from the other transformer. This ranch panel if it does not
> >have the neutral fed into it will be a straight 220 volt three phase
> >delta service. If the neutral leg is present there, he can put 110 volt
> >loads on as well, but has to be careful because the third leg is the
> >"wild leg" and is 208V relative to that neutral, not 110V like the other
> >two hot legs.
> >
> >Diagrams help a lot with this, but I don't think I'm up to trying to
> >draw transformers in ASCII art. There should be some sites with diagrams
> >if you search for "open delta" and "wild leg". Certainly the OP should
> >not go messing around much with his new found three phase service before
> >finding such diagrams and understanding them.
>
> I'll have to have a think about this but what about the phase of each leg?
> A centre tapped transformer will be in phase or 180 degrees out of phase.
>
> A three phase induction motor works with the 3 phases 120 degrees out of
> phase.
>
> In the mean time I'll google "open Delta"
>
> Regards
> Norm
The three hot legs are indeed 120 degrees out of phase since the
transformers are fed from three phase lines. The exact details on the
center tapped transformer vary depending on whether the high side is fed
Wye or Delta, but it doesn't matter much from your perspective since you
still get the expected voltages.
Posted by Neon John on November 4, 2008, 9:04 pm
>> You have 208, not 220 volts.
>No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts commonly
>comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has open delta
>service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild leg" to watch
>out for as well.
Nope. He has 120/240 single phase service and 240 3 phase compliments of the
wild leg that also happens to be nominally 208 volts to neutral, NOT to be
confused with 208/120 delta service. This is called "split open delta" and
not just open delta. It could also be "split closed delta" which is what I
had since I had many more 3 phase loads than the average house. The 3rd
transformer gave me better three phase voltage regulation.
>The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non center
>tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to watch out
>for and he didn't have three phase service.
True.
>His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one of
>the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the 110/220
Please use the modern notation of 120/240. 110/220 has been gone for half a
century. quoting it the old way screws up newbies trying to make the math
work.
>house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch" loads has the
>same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the additional third hot
>leg provided from the other transformer. This ranch panel if it does not
>have the neutral fed into it will be a straight 220 volt three phase
>delta service. If the neutral leg is present there, he can put 110 volt
>loads on as well, but has to be careful because the third leg is the
>"wild leg" and is 208V relative to that neutral, not 110V like the other
>two hot legs.
That is true per the math ( (120+240)/sqrt(3)) ) but the voltages usually
aren't exactly 120 and 240. Mine was a bit high so that my wild leg ran 214
to ground on average.
That was handy for a number of things including operating some British-market
appliances that I had a Brit friend send me. Their system expects 230 on one
leg and neutral on the other. I liked running the wild leg to outlets for
those devices better than I did conventional 240 with each leg 120 to ground.
Just in case the Brit manufacturer took the same shortcuts as US mfrs used to
and tied the neutral to the case.
Since a 240 volt appliance can draw twice the power as a 120 volt appliance
from the same ampacity circuit, Brit stuff is much nicer to use. A tea pot
boils water MUCH faster then even a gas stove heated American one.
John
--
John De Armond
See my website for my current email address
http://www.neon-john.com
http://www.johndearmond.com <-- best little blog on the net!
Tellico Plains, Occupied TN
The profligate use of energy is the sign of a healthy, expanding civilization.
Conservation is a leap backward toward the caves.
> Pete C. wrote:
> > clare@snyder.on.ca wrote:
> >>
> >> On Tue, 4 Nov 2008 07:27:28 +0800, "Norman Webb"
> >>
> >>>
> >>> Norman Webb wrote in message
> >>>>
> >>>> I have read/heard somewhere in the past that 2 transformer 3-phase
> >>>> isnâ?Tt same as industrial service 3-phase â?" is there a
> >>>> difference between residential 3-phase and industrial 3-phase?
> >>>>
> >>>> ##### three phase is three phase. There is difference whether it
> >>>> is used as a star or delta configuration. (I did electrical
> >>>> engineering nearly 30 years ago ,so I am a bit rusty too)
> >>>>
> >>>> ####How many wires are on the power poles out the front? 4 wires
> >>>> means three phase. I haven't heard of two trnasformer, three
> >>>> phase. Is it Single primary with three secondary windings?
> >>>
> >>> Just looked at my statement above. Three phase has each phase out
> >>> of phase by 120 deg so I can't figure out how it would work.
> >>>
> >> You have 208, not 220 volts.
> >
> > No, he has 220 volts, he also has 110 volts and 208V. 208 volts
> > commonly comes with 120/208 volt three phase Wye service, but he has
> > open delta service, and if he has 110 loads off of it he has a "wild
> > leg" to watch out for as well.
> >
> > The transformer that was offline was clearly the one with the non
> > center tapped output, so previously he didn't have that "wild leg" to
> > watch out for and he didn't have three phase service.
> >
> > His "house" 110/220 panel is fed from the center tapped output of one
> > of the transformers, giving him a neutral and two hot legs for the
> > 110/220 house loads. The other three phase panel for the "ranch"
> > loads has the same two hot legs as the "house" panel and has the
> > additional third hot leg provided from the other transformer. This
> > ranch panel if it does not have the neutral fed into it will be a
> > straight 220 volt three phase delta service. If the neutral leg is
> > present there, he can put 110 volt loads on as well, but has to be
> > careful because the third leg is the "wild leg" and is 208V relative
> > to that neutral, not 110V like the other two hot legs.
> >
>
> Well, the 'wild leg' as you call it isn't exactly 208V. If the
> center-tapped side is truly 110/220 and the smaller transformer is also 220,
> then from the third phase to neutral is only 190V.
>
> But still, it's different enough that if you mistakenly use it instead of
> one of the 'hot' legs from the larger, center-tapped transformer, it will
> blow whatever 110V load you hook up to it.
>
> daestrom