Posted by Will on December 29, 2007, 5:40 pm
Does anyone make power meters that allow the usage data to be collected
centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters. I
want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across each
device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating up
the most energy.
There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture the
historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
walk around all day doing spot readings?
There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data, but I
have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally and
then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has the
time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
utilization for the home or business?
The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the spot
data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps, thanks.
:)
I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device is a
true PDU.
There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this area.
There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete wasteland
and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm excluding
the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over weeks
of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills, and
plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or more
per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
energy management decisions. Doing that however might require monitoring
20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
--
Will
Posted by Arnold Walker on December 30, 2007, 2:27 am
Sounds like you are describing a watts up pro es
A little over the 200dollars you mentioned, but the big brother to a Kill a
Watt.
It has a computer plug in ,so that your laptop/ desktop can do anyalsis
work from the readings.
(using software on the cd for the computer)
Far cheaper than industial power management systems from Bradley,etc.
> Does anyone make power meters that allow the usage data to be collected
> centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters. I
> want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
> plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across
> each
> device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating
> up
> the most energy.
> There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
> attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture
> the
> historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
> facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
> walk around all day doing spot readings?
> There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data, but
> I
> have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally and
> then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has
> the
> time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
> utilization for the home or business?
> The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
> wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the
> spot
> data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
> I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps, thanks.
> :)
> I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device is
> a
> true PDU.
> There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this
> area.
> There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
> high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete
> wasteland
> and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm
> excluding
> the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
> simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over
> weeks
> of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills, and
> plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or
> more
> per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
> energy management decisions. Doing that however might require monitoring
> 20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
> spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
> invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
> It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
> technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
> companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
> describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
> --
> Will
>
Posted by Will on December 30, 2007, 5:29 am
> Sounds like you are describing a watts up pro es
> A little over the 200dollars you mentioned, but the big brother to a Kill
a
> Watt.
> It has a computer plug in ,so that your laptop/ desktop can do anyalsis
> work from the readings.
> (using software on the cd for the computer)
> Far cheaper than industial power management systems from Bradley,etc.
So how do I consolidate 20 Watts Up Pro ES units to a single management
station? I have to come up with a serial to TCP/IP conversion for 20
different monitors, and then somehow deal with the software manually
reconnecting to 20 units to gather the data?
Sounds like a part time job to keep up with all of that work....
--
Will
> > Does anyone make power meters that allow the usage data to be collected
> > centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters.
I
> > want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
> > plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across
> > each
> > device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating
> > up
> > the most energy.
> >
> > There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
> > attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture
> > the
> > historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
> > facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
> > walk around all day doing spot readings?
> >
> > There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data,
but
> > I
> > have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally
and
> > then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has
> > the
> > time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
> > utilization for the home or business?
> >
> > The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
> > wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the
> > spot
> > data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
> >
> > I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps,
thanks.
> > :)
> >
> > I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device
is
> > a
> > true PDU.
> >
> > There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this
> > area.
> > There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
> > high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete
> > wasteland
> > and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm
> > excluding
> > the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
> > simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over
> > weeks
> > of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills,
and
> > plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or
> > more
> > per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
> > energy management decisions. Doing that however might require
monitoring
> > 20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
> > spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
> > invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
> >
> > It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
> > technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
> > companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
> > describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
> >
> > --
> > Will
Posted by Will on December 30, 2007, 2:11 pm
> Sounds like you are describing a watts up pro es
> A little over the 200dollars you mentioned, but the big brother to a Kill
a
> Watt.
> It has a computer plug in ,so that your laptop/ desktop can do anyalsis
> work from the readings.
> (using software on the cd for the computer)
> Far cheaper than industial power management systems from Bradley,etc.
Looks like Watts Up is about to release a ".NET" version that lets you
upload data by TCP to their public web site. That looks more promising
and I'll have a look.
--
Will
> > Does anyone make power meters that allow the usage data to be collected
> > centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters.
I
> > want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
> > plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across
> > each
> > device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating
> > up
> > the most energy.
> >
> > There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
> > attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture
> > the
> > historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
> > facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
> > walk around all day doing spot readings?
> >
> > There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data,
but
> > I
> > have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally
and
> > then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has
> > the
> > time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
> > utilization for the home or business?
> >
> > The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
> > wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the
> > spot
> > data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
> >
> > I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps,
thanks.
> > :)
> >
> > I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device
is
> > a
> > true PDU.
> >
> > There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this
> > area.
> > There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
> > high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete
> > wasteland
> > and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm
> > excluding
> > the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
> > simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over
> > weeks
> > of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills,
and
> > plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or
> > more
> > per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
> > energy management decisions. Doing that however might require
monitoring
> > 20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
> > spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
> > invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
> >
> > It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
> > technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
> > companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
> > describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
> >
> > --
> > Will
Posted by spaco on December 30, 2007, 3:32 pm
Try www.dataq.com. I see input devices ("amplifiers" or
"conditioners") for about $89 each that can sense what you say you want.
That leaves you 2 grand for the DAU plus software. I see DAU's with at
least 16 inputs. Should work out okay with your $200 per receptacle
budget. If you have some electronics expertise, you should be able to
do the "conditioning" stuff yourself.
If all the receptacles are 120 volts, then all you REALLY need is to
measure current. Even if some are 220, you already know that THAT'S
always going to be 220, so you still need only measure current, letting
you analysis software multiply the appropriate voltage. If you are
really fussy because of some highly inductive loads, you need to measure
KVARS, etc. and you are on your own.
Pete Stanaitis
----------------------
Will wrote:
> Does anyone make power meters that allow the usage data to be collected
> centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters. I
> want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
> plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across each
> device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating up
> the most energy.
>
> There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
> attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture the
> historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
> facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
> walk around all day doing spot readings?
>
> There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data, but I
> have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally and
> then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has the
> time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
> utilization for the home or business?
>
> The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
> wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the spot
> data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
>
> I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps, thanks.
> :)
>
> I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device is a
> true PDU.
>
> There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this area.
> There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
> high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete wasteland
> and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm excluding
> the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
> simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over weeks
> of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills, and
> plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or more
> per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
> energy management decisions. Doing that however might require monitoring
> 20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
> spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
> invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
>
> It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
> technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
> companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
> describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
>
> centrally and graphed over time? I am NOT looking for panel meters. I
> want meters that either replace a wall receptacle or will act as a PDU
> plugging into a wall socket. The application is power metering across
> each
> device within a building, in order to determine which devices are eating
> up
> the most energy.
> There are many consumer level power meters that show a readout on an LCD
> attached to the meter. That's not my application. It doesn't capture
> the
> historical usage that is so important to my overall goal, and it doesn't
> facilitate a higher level aggregation of the data. And who has time to
> walk around all day doing spot readings?
> There are many PDUs that have built in web pages that show power data, but
> I
> have not found any (yet) that allow the data to be collected centrally and
> then graphed historically, by device, or collectively. Again, who has
> the
> time to connect to 20 web pages to get a collective view of power
> utilization for the home or business?
> The meters would obviously need TCP/IP connectivity (either RJ-45 or
> wireless) and some software that could be run centrally to download the
> spot
> data from each meter and then store those readings in a database.
> I am not looking for a home engineering project with meter clamps, thanks.
> :)
> I need to be at or under $200/meter, a bit more than that if the device is
> a
> true PDU.
> There appears to be a real lack of imagination among products in this
> area.
> There are dozens of products chasing the high end of the market, selling
> high end panel meters to utility companies. There is a complete
> wasteland
> and dearth of products selling to the low end of the market. I'm
> excluding
> the spot monitoring devices like "Kill-a-Watt" because they are way too
> simplistic to deal with understanding overall energy utilization over
> weeks
> of time. Yet there are plenty of consumers with $600 utility bills, and
> plenty of businesses with $3K utility bills, who could be saving $2K or
> more
> per year off those bills if they had data on which to make intelligent
> energy management decisions. Doing that however might require monitoring
> 20 outlets in a home or business. No one gets return on investment
> spending $1K per outlet for a high end power meter because they have to
> invest $20K to save $2K annually. It's a bad investment.
> It is a travesty that with all of the competitive businesses that are
> technically able to deliver these kinds of products, that few or no
> companies have seen the market opportunity for the kinds of meters I am
> describing. Has anyone found anything even close?
> --
> Will
>