Posted by Malcom \"Mal\" Reynolds on June 4, 2010, 7:29 pm
wrote:
<snip>
>
> Our Capt. Tyler represented south coast fishermen during the dungeness
> crab price negotiations this year for the first time. It was crazy. The
> big buyers sent professional negotiators with lawyers and teams of people
> while we had like five captains from up and down the coast. They did all
> they could do to pressure and screw us over for a few extra pennies a
> pound knowing that we couldn't hold out because a lot of boat owners had
> payments to make and mouths to feed. It was pretty insane to see how
> that process works when big money goes against small individual
> businesses.
I believe that is why cooperatives, Blue Diamond and Sunkist come to mind, are
formed. No one should get screwed out of a living, but isn't likely that what
the fisherman saved by not having lawyers was more costly in the end?
>
> However, I still do recommend the Honda Generator -- made by a giant
> corporation :)
>
> best
>
> -z
--
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Cras lobortis volutpat
commodo. Morbi lobortis, massa fringilla adipiscing suscipit, velit urna
pharetra neque, non luctus arcu diam vitae justo. Vivamus lacinia scelerisque
ultricies. Nunc lobortis elit ligula. Aliquam sollicitudin nunc sed est gravida
ac viverra tellus ullamcorper. Vivamus non nisi suscipit nisi egestas venenatis.
Donec vitae arcu id urna euismod feugiat. Vivamus porta lobortis ultricies.
Nulla adipiscing tellus a neque vehicula porta. Maecenas volutpat aliquet
sagittis. Proin nisi magna, molestie id volutpat in, tincidunt sed dolor. Nullam
nisi erat, aliquet scelerisque sagittis vitae, pretium accumsan odio. Sed ut mi
iaculis eros rutrum tristique ut nec mi. Aliquam nec augue dui, in mattis urna.
In pretium metus eu diam blandit accumsan. Ut eu lorem sed odio porttitor
blandit.
Posted by z on June 10, 2010, 3:37 pm
>
> <snip>
>>
>> Our Capt. Tyler represented south coast fishermen during the
>> dungeness crab price negotiations this year for the first time. It
>> was crazy. The big buyers sent professional negotiators with lawyers
>> and teams of people while we had like five captains from up and down
>> the coast. They did all they could do to pressure and screw us over
>> for a few extra pennies a pound knowing that we couldn't hold out
>> because a lot of boat owners had payments to make and mouths to feed.
>> It was pretty insane to see how that process works when big money
>> goes against small individual businesses.
>
> I believe that is why cooperatives, Blue Diamond and Sunkist come to
> mind, are formed. No one should get screwed out of a living, but isn't
> likely that what the fisherman saved by not having lawyers was more
> costly in the end?
Hard to say. I know it's been tried and there are some fishing
collectives, but getting boat captains to agree on anything is like
hearding cats. They are all lords of their domain -- even more so than
farmers or ranchers ! At the moment there is a loose association that
sends the five or so captains to do the negotiation for the whole PNW
crab prices (my captain being one this year).
I think what would help is a fund that each boat pays into so when the
price is too low, we can all hold out 'go on strike' if you will. That
fund is used to help the guys make payments during negotiation.
THe big guys know if we threaten to hold out for a better price enough
fishermen will have to fold and go fishing just to make payments so we
have very little negotiation room.
But that smells too much like a union probably.
Posted by vaughn on June 10, 2010, 5:37 pm
> But that smells too much like a union probably.
Careful! There are laws that cover anti-competitive behavior by business.
Labor can organize and bargain collectively, but business can't always do the
same thing. Don't know if that applies to a fishermen.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law
Vaughn
Posted by z on June 10, 2010, 10:25 pm
>
>>
>> But that smells too much like a union probably.
>
> Careful! There are laws that cover anti-competitive behavior by
> business. Labor can organize and bargain collectively, but business
> can't always do the same thing. Don't know if that applies to a
> fishermen. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law
that's interesting. All the big buyers show up to negotiate the price,
so they're doing the same thing. The price gets set for dungeness at
these meetings then that is the price all up and down the whole coast
from Washington down to California.
I wonder if them colluding is illegal. Probably not. I'd probably have
to read more about corn prices or whatnot. I mean it's more like a
commodity price than a wage or a widget or a service.
Well no way it'd ever happen and i'm no lawyer, so maybe not waste my
time on it. Interesting though you bring up the anti-competitive stuff.
Never even thought of that.
>
> Vaughn
>
>
>
>
>
>
Posted by Bruce in alaska on June 11, 2010, 12:21 am
> >
> > But that smells too much like a union probably.
>
> Careful! There are laws that cover anti-competitive behavior by business.
> Labor can organize and bargain collectively, but business can't always do the
> same thing. Don't know if that applies to a fishermen.
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law
>
> Vaughn
Absolutely, it applies to fishermen, and Fish Buyers... There have been
some really BIG lawsuits over Price Fixing in the Fish Biz, up here in
alaska. Collusion can get you a nice stay in the GrayBar Hotel.
--
Bruce in alaska
add <path> after <fast> to reply
> Our Capt. Tyler represented south coast fishermen during the dungeness
> crab price negotiations this year for the first time. It was crazy. The
> big buyers sent professional negotiators with lawyers and teams of people
> while we had like five captains from up and down the coast. They did all
> they could do to pressure and screw us over for a few extra pennies a
> pound knowing that we couldn't hold out because a lot of boat owners had
> payments to make and mouths to feed. It was pretty insane to see how
> that process works when big money goes against small individual
> businesses.