Posted by Bill on December 28, 2005, 7:00 pm
I have a decent sized "costso" gift certificate for Christmas, which I want
to apply towards a portable generator.... I have 2 basic choices in the
store.
Coleman Powermate 5500 Watt ~ $550
Nikota 3500 Watt ~ $279
My basic questions are;
1. What does 3500 vs. 5500 Watts get me? (generally speaking)
2. If 3500 is enough, is Nikota a brand I should buy?
If it matters,
- This is a typical "emergency" use only purposes.
- I have 2 refridgerators, but I could condense it down to 1 if I had to.
- My stove and oven are gas, so I won't need this for those.
Posted by Harry Chickpea on December 28, 2005, 8:05 pm
>I have a decent sized "costso" gift certificate for Christmas, which I want
>to apply towards a portable generator.... I have 2 basic choices in the
>store.
>Coleman Powermate 5500 Watt ~ $550
>Nikota 3500 Watt ~ $279
>My basic questions are;
>1. What does 3500 vs. 5500 Watts get me? (generally speaking)
>2. If 3500 is enough, is Nikota a brand I should buy?
>If it matters,
>- This is a typical "emergency" use only purposes.
>- I have 2 refridgerators, but I could condense it down to 1 if I had to.
>- My stove and oven are gas, so I won't need this for those.
Think Coleman. 5kw is enough to attach to one element of your water
heater.
Posted by Newby on December 28, 2005, 8:18 pm
> I have a decent sized "costso" gift certificate for Christmas, which I
want
> to apply towards a portable generator.... I have 2 basic choices in the
> store.
> Coleman Powermate 5500 Watt ~ $550
> Nikota 3500 Watt ~ $279
> My basic questions are;
> 1. What does 3500 vs. 5500 Watts get me? (generally speaking)
> 2. If 3500 is enough, is Nikota a brand I should buy?
> If it matters,
> - This is a typical "emergency" use only purposes.
> - I have 2 refridgerators, but I could condense it down to 1 if I had to.
> - My stove and oven are gas, so I won't need this for those.
I have the Coleman and it has been reliable. The unit is built specially
for COSTCO. It is noisy but not intolerable unless you are trying to sleep.
Bought it 6 wks. before Hurricane Isabel. Put about 90 hours on it over the
8 day period we were without power. Charged batteries in the daytime, ran
the refrigerator, washed clothes, ran the microwave and assorted other
stuff. Supplied power to a neighbor for her refrigerator, washing machine
and microwave during the day time as well. Ran my TV and fridge from
inverters at night. My Coleman generator has a Tecumseh engine; some people
say Tecumseh is trash. I have owned Sears, Roebuck lawnmowers (with
Tecumseh engines) for more years than I care to mention and never had a
problem with the engine. Parts are readily available for the engine. If
you have a problem with the Coleman the engine warranty shop and the
generator warranty shop might not be at the same location.
The extra capacity in the Coleman (for the load you identified) means it
will have an easy, and perhaps a long, life until the load starts to creep
up on you... and it will. Don't know anything about the Nikota but suspect
that the 3500 Watts of the Nikota might not be enough as your load begins to
creep up. The surge capacity of the Coleman is much higher than the Nikota.
I am satisfied with my Coleman and will deploy it to one of my sons houses
if needed. I also own a Generac (electric start, 7,500 watts (load creep)
with 13,500 watts surge) and a Honda 2000 for powering the refrigerator at
night.
Based on my experience I would not hesitate to buy the Coleman again.
Regards,
Newby
----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet News==----
http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+
Newsgroups
----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =----
Posted by Eric on December 29, 2005, 2:18 am
Newby wrote:
>
>> I have a decent sized "costso" gift certificate for Christmas, which I
> want
>> to apply towards a portable generator.... I have 2 basic choices in the
>> store.
>>
>> Coleman Powermate 5500 Watt ~ $550
>> Nikota 3500 Watt ~ $279
>>
>> My basic questions are;
>>
>> 1. What does 3500 vs. 5500 Watts get me? (generally speaking)
>> 2. If 3500 is enough, is Nikota a brand I should buy?
>>
>> If it matters,
>>
>> - This is a typical "emergency" use only purposes.
>> - I have 2 refridgerators, but I could condense it down to 1 if I had to.
>> - My stove and oven are gas, so I won't need this for those.
>>
>
> I have the Coleman and it has been reliable. The unit is built specially
> for COSTCO. It is noisy but not intolerable unless you are trying to
> sleep.
> Bought it 6 wks. before Hurricane Isabel. Put about 90 hours on it over
> the
> 8 day period we were without power. Charged batteries in the daytime, ran
> the refrigerator, washed clothes, ran the microwave and assorted other
> stuff. Supplied power to a neighbor for her refrigerator, washing machine
> and microwave during the day time as well. Ran my TV and fridge from
> inverters at night. My Coleman generator has a Tecumseh engine; some
> people
> say Tecumseh is trash. I have owned Sears, Roebuck lawnmowers (with
> Tecumseh engines) for more years than I care to mention and never had a
> problem with the engine. Parts are readily available for the engine. If
> you have a problem with the Coleman the engine warranty shop and the
> generator warranty shop might not be at the same location.
>
> The extra capacity in the Coleman (for the load you identified) means it
> will have an easy, and perhaps a long, life until the load starts to creep
> up on you... and it will. Don't know anything about the Nikota but
> suspect that the 3500 Watts of the Nikota might not be enough as your load
> begins to
> creep up. The surge capacity of the Coleman is much higher than the
> Nikota.
>
> I am satisfied with my Coleman and will deploy it to one of my sons houses
> if needed. I also own a Generac (electric start, 7,500 watts (load creep)
> with 13,500 watts surge) and a Honda 2000 for powering the refrigerator at
> night.
>
> Based on my experience I would not hesitate to buy the Coleman again.
>
> Regards,
> Newby
>
>
>
> ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet
> News==---- http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World!
> 120,000+ Newsgroups ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy
> via Encryption =----
How's the Generac? Any good? noisy or quiet?
Eric
Posted by Newby on December 29, 2005, 8:03 am
> Newby wrote:
> >
[snipped]
> >
> > I am satisfied with my Coleman and will deploy it to one of my sons
houses
> > if needed. I also own a Generac (electric start, 7,500 watts (load
creep)
> > with 13,500 watts surge) and a Honda 2000 for powering the refrigerator
at
> > night.
> >
> > Based on my experience I would not hesitate to buy the Coleman again.
> >
> > Regards,
> > Newby
> >
> >
> How's the Generac? Any good? noisy or quiet?
> Eric
The Generac has been run about 20 hours, without any problem) and is not as
loud (purely subjective as no measurements have been taken) as the Coleman.
In the day time the noise difference is not significant. Might be a
different story at 2200 hrs. as the ambient noise level is down in general.
I especially like the electric starter.
Newby
----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet News==----
http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+
Newsgroups
----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =----
>to apply towards a portable generator.... I have 2 basic choices in the
>store.
>Coleman Powermate 5500 Watt ~ $550
>Nikota 3500 Watt ~ $279
>My basic questions are;
>1. What does 3500 vs. 5500 Watts get me? (generally speaking)
>2. If 3500 is enough, is Nikota a brand I should buy?
>If it matters,
>- This is a typical "emergency" use only purposes.
>- I have 2 refridgerators, but I could condense it down to 1 if I had to.
>- My stove and oven are gas, so I won't need this for those.