Posted by Jimes on July 3, 2006, 2:09 pm
I see lots of talk about the low power consumption of the low power lights,
but I'm missing something...
Normally, people speak about a preference for a 100W light or a 60W light,
beacuse they are concerned with the amount of light produced. Now the Watt
rating actually refers to it's consumption, and not the amount of light
produced.
I personally think the low voltage 50W bulbs give the best light, and these
9W minature flourescents the worst, but I'm speaking about the quality of
the light produced. The low voltage lights produce a full bodied pyramid of
light, whilst these 9W low power ones produce a sickly sort half hearted
light (just an opinion). Fact is though, the 9W lamp is far more attractive
for the minimal power it consumes.
My question is, what are the terms of reference to describe the amount of
light given off, (not the power consumed)?
Thanks
Jimes
Posted by Jimes on July 3, 2006, 3:17 pm
Partial answer to my own question....
I'm looking at lumens per watt....but if the manufacturer of the light bulb
like Phillips doesn't put it on the box... can it be calculated?
Jimes
"Jimes" <k> wrote in message
>I see lots of talk about the low power consumption of the low power lights,
>but I'm missing something...
> Normally, people speak about a preference for a 100W light or a 60W light,
> beacuse they are concerned with the amount of light produced. Now the Watt
> rating actually refers to it's consumption, and not the amount of light
> produced.
> I personally think the low voltage 50W bulbs give the best light, and
> these 9W minature flourescents the worst, but I'm speaking about the
> quality of the light produced. The low voltage lights produce a full
> bodied pyramid of light, whilst these 9W low power ones produce a sickly
> sort half hearted light (just an opinion). Fact is though, the 9W lamp is
> far more attractive for the minimal power it consumes.
> My question is, what are the terms of reference to describe the amount of
> light given off, (not the power consumed)?
> Thanks
> Jimes
>
Posted by William P.N. Smith on July 3, 2006, 3:41 pm
"Jimes" <k> wrote:
>I'm looking at lumens per watt....but if the manufacturer of the light bulb
>like Phillips doesn't put it on the box... can it be calculated?
No, you want total lumens, which tells you how bright a light is. CR
(Color Rendition) is a number used with flourescents to tell you how
'good' a light is (you can somewhat determine this number from the
color temperature of the bulb).
L/W is a measure of efficiency.
Posted by Mary Fisher on July 5, 2006, 11:22 am
> "Jimes" <k> wrote:
>>I'm looking at lumens per watt....but if the manufacturer of the light
>>bulb
>>like Phillips doesn't put it on the box... can it be calculated?
> No, you want total lumens, which tells you how bright a light is. CR
> (Color Rendition) is a number used with flourescents to tell you how
> 'good' a light is (you can somewhat determine this number from the
> color temperature of the bulb).
What does 'good' mean?
I thoroughly dislike what I call the 'quality' of light from long life
bulbs, is this the same thing? They seem to give everything a dull,
yellowish tint. It's very difficult to explain :-(
Mary
Posted by Anthony Matonak on July 5, 2006, 12:48 pm
Mary Fisher wrote:
...
>>No, you want total lumens, which tells you how bright a light is. CR
>>(Color Rendition) is a number used with flourescents to tell you how
>>'good' a light is (you can somewhat determine this number from the
>>color temperature of the bulb).
>
> What does 'good' mean?
Color Rendition index is a method of telling how well a light will
produce the full spectrum. Sunlight is considered the best and
everything else is compared against that standard. A low number
will mean that colors will look different than under sunlight.
> I thoroughly dislike what I call the 'quality' of light from long life
> bulbs, is this the same thing? They seem to give everything a dull,
> yellowish tint. It's very difficult to explain :-(
Yellowish tint is a very good way to explain it. Such a light has
a low color temperature. Color temperature is based on the concept
that with an incandescent light the hotter it is, the more blue the
light it produces. Low temperature incandescent bulbs produce a
very red or orange light. Fluorescents don't work the same way but
it's possible to describe their overall light spectrum by temperature
as if they did.
Personally, the higher the color temperature, the better.
Anthony
>but I'm missing something...
> Normally, people speak about a preference for a 100W light or a 60W light,
> beacuse they are concerned with the amount of light produced. Now the Watt
> rating actually refers to it's consumption, and not the amount of light
> produced.
> I personally think the low voltage 50W bulbs give the best light, and
> these 9W minature flourescents the worst, but I'm speaking about the
> quality of the light produced. The low voltage lights produce a full
> bodied pyramid of light, whilst these 9W low power ones produce a sickly
> sort half hearted light (just an opinion). Fact is though, the 9W lamp is
> far more attractive for the minimal power it consumes.
> My question is, what are the terms of reference to describe the amount of
> light given off, (not the power consumed)?
> Thanks
> Jimes
>