Posted by Frogwatch on March 23, 2009, 3:13 am
I have roughly 20 CFL in my home and they do not perform anywhere near
as well as advertised and my experience goes back as far as CFL do.
They simply do not give out as much light as a comparable
incandascent. They do not last nearly as long as advertised and
often, very often fail much sooner. I have bought some cfl
floodlights where 3 out of 4 in a package were bad. I find that they
DO NOT SAVE MONEY. However, I use them because on average, they last
about 4X as long as incandascents. Thus they are basically an
expensive convenience for me.
Posted by Tim Jackson on March 23, 2009, 11:04 am
That's an interesting observation.
I've never had a bad CFL lamp supplied in this country.
I'll agree that the light output doesn't always seem to reach
expectations, especially during the first five minutes after switch-on.
Both my elderly neighbour and myself have quite a few of these lamps,
and I maintain both. I have noticed that I have to replace her lamps
more often than my own. I attribute this to the fact that I only have
them in locations where they are on for long periods. I have a couple of
3W CFLs as "safety" lights that are on 24/7, and they don't seem to fail
any more often than those that are used frequently for fairly short
periods. Of course this small sample is a way from being statistically
significant, and these casual observations a way from being rigorous.
I have to suspect that despite claims to the contrary, much of the
ageing of these lamps occurs during start-up.
Posted by ransley on March 23, 2009, 11:05 am
You need to buy a good brand with a warranty HDs are cheap with 7 yr
warranty, i have about 70 in use. .All Your findings are flawed. Here
are two independant reviews that compare many CFLs to incandesants.
Posted by harry on March 26, 2009, 8:25 pm
The above is exactly right. Cheap Chinese crap and a horrible colour
some of them too. Get the ones made by Philips & problem is solved.
I have some CFL's in my house that are fifteen years old. The very
first ones to come out. (look like jam jars) They do get a bit dimmer
as the years go by. Technology is now much improved & also you can
get ones that can be dimmed too (cost more). The new ones take a
second to get to full brilliance. Price 0.75 = $ if you buy them in
Readup on this re colour:-
Posted by clare on March 27, 2009, 2:20 am
On Thu, 26 Mar 2009 13:25:44 -0700 (PDT), harry
I still have 2 of the old "circline" CFs floating around that are
over 20 years old. Don't fit much, but they've seen lamp duty and for
a while one was in the furnace room/shop ceiling fixture.