Posted by john private smith on November 5, 2003, 2:36 am
hi, i am considering a grid tie solar PV system for my home, i think a
1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how many people out there
have done this, and of those people my question is this, has the
utility knocked on your door after some period after install wanting
to know why your billed electricity consumption has gone down alot
each month in the last however may months? the reason i ask this is i
want to know how likely the utility companys are to take action
against someone whth a grid tie system...i have talked with 6 people
of our utility and none of them say that customers can connect grid
tie systems in, most did not know what a grid tie system was. several
cited safety concerns for lineman workers if power were to fail
(current production grid tie systems by xantrex prevent islanding, but
the utility people didnot care) i know if i pay the big cash upfront
for this system, i would like to know my chances of having the utility
say i have to disconnect the system.
i dont like the thought of continuing to support fossil fuel and oil
dependancy, i want to do my part to make america less dependent on
foreign oil sources. please let me know what your expierence is with
utilitys.
thanks,
jack
Posted by Duane C. Johnson on November 5, 2003, 7:12 am
Hi john;
> hi, i am considering a grid tie solar PV system for my home,
> i think a 1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how
> many people out there have done this,
Lots. Well lots is a relative term. But there are quite a few.
Read about many in the Home Power" magazine. See:
http://www.homepower.com
> and of those people my question is this,
> has the utility knocked on your door after some period
> after install wanting to know why your billed electricity
> consumption has gone down alot each month in the last
> however may months?
That scenario can happen if you did it without telling them.
That method has been referred to as going "Guerilla".
http://windturbine.ca/guerilla.html
Or a search:
http://www.google.com/search?&q=+"guerilla+power"&btnG=Search
http://www.google.com/search?&q=+"guerilla+solar"&btnG=Search
> the reason i ask this is i want to know how likely the
> utility companys are to take action against someone whth
> a grid tie system...
And they can shut you down if you haven't followed the rules.
> i have talked with 6 people of our utility and none of
>them say that customers can connect grid tie systems in,
> most did not know what a grid tie system was.
They were uninformed. Federal law requires the grid companies
to allow intertie connections. If the rules are followed.
> several cited safety concerns for lineman workers if power
> were to fail (current production grid tie systems by
> xantrex prevent islanding, but the utility people didn't
> care)
Again, they were uninformed. The Xantrex inverter, and
others, pass pas the IEEE specified requirements.
> i know if i pay the big cash upfront for this system,
> i would like to know my chances of having the utility
> say i have to disconnect the system.
They won't if you follow the rules.
They may if you go Guerilla.
It's up to you which way you go.
> i dont like the thought of continuing to support fossil
> fuel and oil dependancy, i want to do my part to make
> america less dependent on foreign oil sources.
> please let me know what your expierence is with utilitys.
> thanks, jack
Duane
--
Home of the $35 Solar Tracker Receiver
http://www.redrok.com/electron.htm#led3X [*]
Powered by \ \ \ //|
Thermonuclear Solar Energy from the Sun / |
Energy (the SUN) \ \ \ / / |
Red Rock Energy \ \ / / |
Duane C. Johnson Designer \ \ / \ / |
1825 Florence St Heliostat,Control,& Mounts |
White Bear Lake, Minnesota === \ / \ |
USA 55110-3364 === \ |
(651)426-4766 use Courier New Font \ |
redrok@redrok.com (my email: address) \ |
http://www.redrok.com (Web site) ===
Posted by bob on November 5, 2003, 5:26 pm
On Wed, 05 Nov 2003 06:12:11 -0600, "Duane C. Johnson"
>Hi john;
>> hi, i am considering a grid tie solar PV system for my home,
>> i think a 1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how
>> many people out there have done this,
>> several cited safety concerns for lineman workers if power
>> were to fail (current production grid tie systems by
>> xantrex prevent islanding, but the utility people didn't
>> care)
>Again, they were uninformed. The Xantrex inverter, and
>others, pass pas the IEEE specified requirements.
Yes, and for the small, less than 10KW grid tie systems, even if the
anti-islanding were not perfect, the inverters would more than likely
be shorted out from the loaded grid and stop producing. As it is now,
they have about 2 seconds or so in which to disconnect from grid.
bob
>> thanks, jack
>Duane
Posted by Solar Guppy on November 5, 2003, 9:49 pm
Its 50 milliseconds out of range voltage and/or frequency , single cycle for
substantial over-voltage conditions (16.66ms)
UL-1741 specifies this , which is what all US based grid-tie inverters are
designed/tested too
> On Wed, 05 Nov 2003 06:12:11 -0600, "Duane C. Johnson"
> >Hi john;
> >
> >
> >> hi, i am considering a grid tie solar PV system for my home,
> >> i think a 1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how
> >> many people out there have done this,
> >
> >
> >> several cited safety concerns for lineman workers if power
> >> were to fail (current production grid tie systems by
> >> xantrex prevent islanding, but the utility people didn't
> >> care)
> >
> >Again, they were uninformed. The Xantrex inverter, and
> >others, pass pas the IEEE specified requirements.
> >
> Yes, and for the small, less than 10KW grid tie systems, even if the
> anti-islanding were not perfect, the inverters would more than likely
> be shorted out from the loaded grid and stop producing. As it is now,
> they have about 2 seconds or so in which to disconnect from grid.
> bob
> >> thanks, jack
> >
> >Duane
Posted by bob on November 9, 2003, 12:40 am
On Thu, 06 Nov 2003 02:49:15 GMT, "Solar Guppy"
>Its 50 milliseconds out of range voltage and/or frequency , single cycle for
>substantial over-voltage conditions (16.66ms)
>UL-1741 specifies this , which is what all US based grid-tie inverters are
>designed/tested too
Is that UL1741 possibly the draft of the new version ???
The one I'm looking at now, January 17,2001 says 2 seconds if the
voltage falls between .5 and .88 of Vnormal, and 1.1 to 1.37 of
Vnormal (at rated frequency))
OR
100 milliseconds if the voltage falls to less than 1/2 of
the normal voltage or the frequency goes below rated F - .7 Hz,
or greater than .5 Hz above rated frequency (so between 59.3Hz and
60.5 Hz)
Either way, it's still pretty fast response to drop in grid. :-)
bob
>> On Wed, 05 Nov 2003 06:12:11 -0600, "Duane C. Johnson"
>>
>> >Hi john;
>> >
>> >
>> >> hi, i am considering a grid tie solar PV system for my home,
>> >> i think a 1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how
>> >> many people out there have done this,
>> >
>>
>> >
>> >> several cited safety concerns for lineman workers if power
>> >> were to fail (current production grid tie systems by
>> >> xantrex prevent islanding, but the utility people didn't
>> >> care)
>> >
>> >Again, they were uninformed. The Xantrex inverter, and
>> >others, pass pas the IEEE specified requirements.
>> >
>>
>>
>> Yes, and for the small, less than 10KW grid tie systems, even if the
>> anti-islanding were not perfect, the inverters would more than likely
>> be shorted out from the loaded grid and stop producing. As it is now,
>> they have about 2 seconds or so in which to disconnect from grid.
>>
>> bob
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> >> thanks, jack
>> >
>> >Duane
>>
>>
> i think a 1KW system will be fine for me, but i wonder how
> many people out there have done this,